Not only had I never baked a sweet potato pie before this one but I also had never tasted one either! I had heard from others that sweet potato can be even better than pumpkin for pie but I never believed it… until now. After getting around 3lbs of sweet potatoes from a local farm, I decided that it was finally time to experiment with sweet potato pie.
I didn’t like most of the recipes I found online, each one for a different reason. So, I combined and adapted several to come up with my own. Though they weren’t the most beautiful pies because the crusts were a little shallow and uneven, husband and neighbors loved them.
Pie Ingredients (yields two pies, cut quantities in half for a single pie)
- pie dough (for example, the one I made here)
- 3 cups cooked and peeled sweet potatoes
- 6 eggs (yolks and whites separated)
- 1.5 cups brown sugar
- 1.5 cups milk
- 1 cup melted butter
- 1 tsp cinnamon
- 1/2 tsp ground ginger
- 1/4 tsp nutmeg
- 2 tsp vanilla extract
- 1/2 tsp sea salt
Maple Whipped Cream (optional)
- 1 cup whipping cream
- 1-2 tbs maple syrup
Make and chill dough for a pie crust of your liking. If you’re making two pies, use a double pie crust recipe. I was just a little bit short on dough and so my edges didn’t come out as high and wide as I would have liked. While your dough chills, start by boiling the sweet potatoes over medium heat for about an hour. After they cook, drain them, let them cool, peel them, and chop/mash before using.
I like to blind bake my pie crust for about 15 minutes at 350°F to make sure that the bottom cooks through and gets nice and flaky. It was my first time using this method with parchment paper and a pie chain. I discovered that the sides of the pie sink down a bit with this method – not ideal but still better than soggy/raw crust. Next time, I might try filling the paper with dried beans instead to see if it does a better job of providing structure for the sides.
While the crusts cook, prepare the pie filling. Combine all of the ingredients in one bowl except for the egg whites (and also the pie dough, of course). Start by beating the yolks with the brown sugar, add in the spices, melted butter, milk, and lastly the sweet potatoes. You can use a hand mixer to get a smooth texture. Next, beat the egg whites with a clean hand mixer until peaks form but they’re still glossy and wet.
Gently fold the beaten egg whites into the rest of the mixture until just combined. Pour the filling into the cooled pie crusts. Bake at 350°F for approximately 50 minutes or until the filling looks set.
You’ll notice that the pie puffs up a little bit like a soufflé while baking. When you take it out of the oven and let it cool it will deflate back down but will keep a light texture from those beaten egg whites. Let the pie cool to room temperature and serve with a dollop of freshly whipped cream, lightly sweetened with maple syrup.